Every city has that restaurant that regulars know about and visitors stumble onto and immediately regret not finding sooner. In Wichita Falls, that place is Mario's Pizza by the Slice. Opened on Sheppard Access Rd with a clear vision — hand-tossed New York-style pizza, sold by the slice or the whole pie, at prices that make it a real everyday option — Mario's has delivered on that promise and then some. Classic slices at $3.99 and Sicilian at $4.99 make walking in for a quick lunch one of the easiest decisions in town, and the quality waiting inside makes it one of the best.
The menu at Mario's is worth spending time with. The 14 specialty pizzas range from straightforward crowd-pleasers — the Grandma Pizza with mozzarella, garlic, basil, and olive oil over pecorino romano, or the Buffalo Pizza with breaded chicken and a blue cheese drizzle — to more adventurous builds like the Trio with marinara, vodka, and pesto layered over the same crust, or the Capricciosa with pomodoro tomatoes, mushrooms, prosciutto, and artichokes. Specialty pies run $25.99 for Classic and $26.99 for Sicilian. The build-your-own path offers 24 toppings, specialty sauces, and drizzle options for those who want full creative control. Garlic knots, buffalo wings, and Italian cheesecakes round out a menu that has something for everyone at the table.
The reviews at Mario's are not just positive — they are enthusiastic, with customers calling it the best pizza in Wichita Falls and comparing it favorably to the best slice shops they have visited across the country. You will find Mario's at 3604 Sheppard Access Rd in Wichita Falls, open Tuesday through Sunday from 10 AM to 7 PM. Give them a call at 940-228-5506 to place your order — or let the menu do the convincing first.